Kyshtym-zilla

In 1957, there was a nuclear disaster in a city called Cheliabinsk-40 in the Ural Mountains of the Soviet Union, the blow came from an underground tank filled with radioactive waste. The “Kyshtym Disaster” is the third biggest nuclear disaster in history, according to the International Nuclear Event Scale, behind the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster in 2011 and the Chernobyl Nuclear disaster in 1986 (which takes the top spot). How is it that the “Kyshtym Disaster” is widely unheard of?

Within the Soviet Union there were ten of these ‘nuclear cities‘, those employed within these cities were to keep their activities extremely secret and would be paid high wages for their dangerous work. Aside from the high confidentiality of their employment, families who lived in these cities enjoyed a wide range of functions provided by the state such as housing, health care, and good educational opportunities. Though, these communities were extremely high risk not only because they were in the midst of nuclear plants but also because the Soviet nuclear program was rushed in order to compete with America’s nuclear weapons technology. Conditions within these cities were unsafe to begin with. Another contributor to the danger of the nuclear city was that workers at the plant would also dump nuclear waste into the Techa River, other solid materials that were dumped on the site polluted the air along with smoke that came from the plant itself.

800px-Ecodefense_Mayak_Exhibition_26_Reserve
Warning sign at the Mayak Plant

The plant at Cheliabinsk-40, called the Mayak Plant, had six reactors which processed nuclear materials to create plutonium for nuclear weapons. Specifically, what happened on the day of the explosion was that one of the cooling systems at Mayak failed. These cooling systems were integral to the processing of nuclear material at the plant because liquid nuclear waste is extremely hot, and the cooling tanks were meant to prevent the dangers of overheating. When one of the cooling systems failed, radioactive chemical dust was created when the waste tank got too hot and surrounding water evaporated. The product of the cooling system failure was radioactive ammonium-nitrate, which was released into the air when the waste tank exploded.

Although 270,000 people lived in Ozyorsk (the true name of the city) only 11,000 of them evacuated within two years after the disaster. Residents and those near the plant began to see the effects of the blast when they noticed that their skin was falling off or when they started to get sores on their skin. In order to lessen panic and doubt that the city wasn’t safe, Soviet authorities spent 11 million rubles (about $150,000 today) on public relations and also forbade any more people from coming in, including soldiers and clean up workers.

The population who felt the effects of the disaster the most were the farmers surrounding the city, which were about 87 villages who were in the process of harvesting their crop for the year. Farmers in the village of Korabolka had seen the nuclear blast, and some even believed that a nuclear war had started. Effects were seen quickly as 300 out of 5000 villagers died of radiation poisoning. Another favored population within the disaster were ethnic Russian villagers who were relocated, the remaining ethnic Tartars stayed in the contaminated villages. Soldiers also relocated the most contaminated villages, though, relocation proved to be too expensive if it were to be done for all the villages in the area so many were left behind. Later on, the people at Korabolka would experience five times the cancer rate of those who lived in uncontaminated villages, other contaminated villages would have higher rates of cancer, genetic abnormalities, and other radiation-related illnesses. Soldiers who arrived at the farms after the blast instructed villagers to bury that year’s contaminated harvest, the villagers themselves took on the hard task of doing so.

It is evident that the Soviet government purposefully left the most affected populations in the dark of what really happened at Mayak. To no one’s surprise, the Soviets would also keep the disaster at Kyshtym (the closest mapped city to Ozyorsk) a secret to the rest of the world. The Soviet regime could not afford to have its nuclear failure out for everyone to see.

zhores-medvedev-american-philosophical-society
Zhores Medvedev, Russian biologist and dissident

In 1976 a Russian biologist named Zhores Medvedev exposed the Kyshtym disaster to the world and also brought to light other problematic science-related issues within the USSR. In his article named “Two decades of dissidence“, Medvedev begins by explaining Stalin’s mishandlings of science in his regime, specifically, he explains that Stalin supported scientists who professed to be able to achieve something extraordinary. This led Stalin to support scientists who were unqualified and had aspirations that were completely unrealistic, in response, a dissident scientist movement began. To be apart of the movement was extremely risky because it meant going against state-sanctioned science.

Khrushchev’s de-Stalinization movement allowed credible scientists to have more wiggle-room in the USSR. Though, under Krushchev’s regime the most elite of scientists were nuclear physicists and aerospace  technologists, other scientists like geneticists were suppressed. Before the Kyshtym disaster, geneticists tried to warn nuclear physicists about the dangers of radiation and radioactivity on human populations. The lack of interest and scientific knowledge on radiation genetics and radiology became extremely evident in the aftermath of the disaster, when no one knew how to treat those who were affected by radiation from the blast. This forced the Soviet government to legalize genetics for radiology, radiobiology, and medicine.

The Kyshtym disaster is an episode in both world history and Soviet history on how the nuclear hubris of regimes can cost the lives of hundreds of people, and how its effects are felt after decades after an instantaneous blast. We may never know the true number of innocent people who were affected by the disaster, adding to the list of the many secrets from the Soviet Union that has continued to baffle the modern world.

23 thoughts on “Kyshtym-zilla

  1. Hi Joy! I’ve always been intrigued by stuff like this, so I really enjoyed this post. I had no idea that this had occurred, which is crazy because one would think that with this being the 3rd worst nuclear disaster it would be publicized more. I also think it’s crazy that they would spend so much money on a coverup and forbidding others to come in, instead of spending that money to clean up and help the people. Good for Medvedev for exposing this though! Great job!

    Like

    1. Hey Lauren! Thank you! I am also into eerie stuff like this, and I was also really surprised that it was the number three nuclear disaster in the whole world. I think its kind of astonishing that the Soviets were able to cover up the entire thing, but in a way that was pretty irresponsible because they didn’t properly asses the affects of the blow. I really look up to Medvedev for exposing what happened, its probably wasn’t the easiest thing to do during this era.

      Like

  2. Joy, I enjoyed this post on the Kyshtym disaster. I also had never heard of this nuclear disaster but its effects are devastating. Your post reminds me of the book “Biohazard” by Ken Alibek. It’s chilling to know that many innocent people had no idea what the consequences of their exposure would be and that the Russian government declined to tell them and allowed them to live so close to the nuclear sites.

    Like

    1. Hey Natalie! I also was supposed to read Biohazard for a class but… it did not end up happening for me. Though, I do think that it was widely irresponsible for the government to not tell the villagers around the plant about what really happened. But some part of me is wondering whether they just chose to neglect the effects of radiation, or if they genuinely didn’t think there weren’t any effects at all. All in all, it was horrible for the Soviets to kind of just pack up and leave while these innocent people’s skin was falling off.

      Like

  3. My goodness, I’m glad you informed us about this incident and the Soviet’s gross handling of the situation. I was wondering though, that if you knew if this incident provided the Soviets with knowledge on how to better handle these disasters and prevent them?

    Like

    1. Hi Alyssa, yes! The Soviets actually did use what happened in the aftermath of the Kyshtym disaster when assessing what happened at Chernobyl. The Soviets didn’t really have the best track record when it came to nuclear facilities around civilians, huh. I just wish that these villagers didn’t have to serve as unintended-experiments in order for the Soviets to figure out what and what not to do when it came to nuclear sites.

      Like

  4. This is such an interesting post! I had never heard of this incident before reading it, and I agree with Lauren that these kind of things are fascinating to me. The fact that they were able to cover it up so well for almost 20 years is both amazing and terrifying, and it is troubling that only certain populations were relocated based on ethnicity and expenses. I also enjoyed learning about how certain scientific fields were valued under different regimes, and although it makes sense I was unaware that it went on.

    Like

    1. Thank you so much! One thing that I hope to get around watching is Chernobyl TV show that came out last year (I think). So even though I haven’t seen it, I would like to recommend it to you and Lauren! But yeah, the whole thing was kind of crazier and even crazier that it is still not widely known about in the public eye. I would think by post-WWII that people would understand that being associated with anything nuclear was probably dangerous, but I guess the work at the plants and the functions that the Soviets provided were just too good to resist. Also Medvedev goes to show that science is definitely political.

      Like

  5. Khystym-zilla indeed! I agree with all of the comments you’ve got about how the handling of the disaster reflected and informed the regime’s priorities. Also, your timing with this is perfect, as there are currently wildfires raging in the Chernobyl zone that everyone worried about a new radioactive flare-up there on top of all of the pandemic danger. I really love how you highlight Medvedev’s role in bringing Khystym to light. Many scholars and scientists worked to hold the regime accountable, even when they knew it could ruin their careers. Sakharov is certainly the most famous, but Medvedev and his twin brother (the historian!) Roy, deserve more credit.
    There’s a great book by Anne Garrels (of Naked in Baghdad fame) called, Putin Country, that’s largely based on interviews from Cheliabinsk. It’s wild.
    Also — the photograph from the Mayak plant really made me chuckle: it says “Nature Preserve” below the atomic sign.

    Like

    1. Hey Professor! Actually, I thought it was really weird how when I tried to find out what that photograph really said, no websites would actually list what it meant in English? I even tried to run the photo through an image-to-text generator, and it came up with absolutely nothing. Also, I had no idea about the Chernobyl fires! I truly think that Medvedev was a (for lack of a better term) badass for being so open about what was going on behind the scenes regarding science during the space race and the nuclear arms race (he even talked about Dr. Lysenko).

      Liked by 1 person

  6. Joy, yes the Cheliabinsk-40 was a disaster for the area around the site. The wind carried the radioactive isotopes of cesium-137 and strontium-90 in the ammonium nitrate paste and that radioactive paste did the long-lasting damage to the lands. The long half life of the isotopes means that the problem is still there as Dr. Nelson pointed out with the fires burning around the Chernobyl plant that had some similar nuclear isotope waste.

    Like

    1. Hey Tom! Regarding what you said about half life, I really tried to note at the end of my blogpost that although nuclear disasters may take place in mere seconds, the affects of them last for longer than a human lifetime. The farming land is going to be contaminated for a long time and people living in the area will definitely suffer mutations, defects, and other illnesses related to the blast for some generations. Definitely something to consider when it comes to using nuclear power.

      Like

  7. Joy, I absolutely loved you post! Like many others, I wasn’t even aware that this happened. However, your recognition of this incident, a lack of Soviet concern, Medvedev’s dissidence, and so many other things were fantastic to read about. I especially appreciated the last paragraph, and your statement on how the hubris of nuclear stares can have serious consequences for general populations. The race to space, the development of ICBMs, and the nuclear arms race are all proof of this. Right now, I think we’re living through a time where we’re trying to figure out if nuclear states have learned their lessons, and I certainly hope they have.

    Like

    1. Kendall! Researching this topic has also made me question a lot of things regarding nuclear power in all countries who harness it. In today’s context, nuclear deterrence and the morality of even having nuclear weapons is a hard thing to navigate. While one, nuclear weapons serve no purpose but to destroy, and while two, countries use the posession of nuclear power to prove that they are not a force to be reckoned with, ultimately, it would be extremely difficult to get rid of these weapons because there is absolutely no mutual trust between nuclear states to do so. I think it’ll take a long time for these powers to realize what they’ve done and what pandora box they’ve opened.

      Like

  8. This was a very interesting read. I guess the Soviet Union did not want the United States to see how bad its nuclear program was going based off its reaction to Ozyorsk. I was surprised that people would want to live in a nuclear town based off of what happened in World War II. I was also surprised that Stalin hired scientists who talked of great things but had no experience in the field. I guess that is a major reason why these disasters happened.

    Like

    1. Hey Matt! Yes. There are very surprising things that are related to the Soviet Union, and that within itself is not surprising at all. But you raise something that I haven’t thought about too, I don’t understand why people would want to live in these cities or work in these plants when they had seen or head of the horrors of the Japan bombings.

      Like

  9. Very interesting read. Similar to comment above I really do wonder how much of their efforts to keep this under the wrap was because of the cold war with the United States. Both countries certainly wanted to look perfect so makes sense they didn’t want this out. Also like some people in this post I really had no idea this happened. I just knew about Chernobyl.

    Like

    1. Thank you! Actually when writing the post I did know that I wanted to write about something nuclear related, but I didn’t know when I chose Kyshtym was that it was the third worst nuclear disaster in history. Its kind of amazing how the Soviets could cover up something as big as this in the late 1950s. I would like to think it was easier for the Soviets to keep it concealed because it happened on remote, Soviet lands (in comparison to what happened during the Cuban Missile Crisis).

      Like

  10. Hi Joy, such a great blog post! Research for my blog post I also read that Stalin made the nuclear arms programs top priority after having a meeting with the U.S. and the president at the time mentioned briefly to Stalin that they had a nuclear arms program. That was when Stalin wanted the scientist and engineers to speed up the creation of the program. During my research, there was no mention of this particular disaster and you are very right on how the Soviet Union could cover up such an enormous disaster.

    Like

    1. Hi Siria! From my own knowledge I didn’t know that the nuclear arms race was so important during this time (I thought it became more important during the Brezhnev era), I thought the more prominent race was the space race. After learning that Stalin was interested in besting America at everything it suddenly made sense why the Soviets rushed everything and why everything was in horrible conditions. When it comes to nuclear power and weapons there are definitely unintended consequences when one engages in it recklessly.

      Like

  11. Joy, it was good to read your post. I’ve heard of Chernobyl but I was unaware of Khystym! It’s interesting how much effort Stalin put into the nuclear program. My favorite part about your post was the nuclear cities. I would like to hear from some of the people who worked in them.

    Like

    1. Chris! I would also love to know about how people felt living in these nuclear cities. I still would regard working for any nuclear programs cool, but as we all know today it is riddled with danger. I would also like to know how evacuated workers reacted when they found out about how all the villagers were affected by the radiation blast.

      Like

Leave a comment